« A Sentimental Story | Main | Wetdown »

February 19, 2006
Kinder and gentler?
Posted by JP at 07:16 PM in Military life | Comments (1)

Via Paw Paw I found this post at Snugg Harbor. Read the whole thing.

In my line of work, folks are more likely to get killed in a car wreck on the way home, or drown while kayaking on their day off. Not the most dangerous job in the world.

There is stress, however. One evening I helped author a report that went straight to a pair of Generals. It wasn't stressful in the hope I impress the brass sort of way. This pair of flag officers were hours away from making a decision; that decision was going to be based in part on the assesment myself and another NCO produced. It was imperative that these two officers were given a concise, accurate assesment of the facts, along with the recommendation of the office the sarge and I respresented. And we had under three hours to get it done and out the door. And the folks with the best technical knowledge weren't around; it was sometime after midnight.

If the two flag officers made a poor decision, the NY Times would have a field day reporting on the disaster that followed.

Two things stuck in my head during that three hour period. First, the stress I felt was nothing compared to some of Coach DeSimone's wrestling practices back in High School. Second, the stress I felt was nothing compared to every waking hour of basic training. While you cannot mandate high school athletics for every potential soldier, sailor, marine, or airman you can mandate a rigorous basic military training course.

Basic training is a hostile workplace. You are convinced that if your t-shirt isn't folded exactly the right way, there's a physical punishment or potential discharge from the military right around the corner. It's an alternate universe where nothing you do is right, everything you do results in being screamed at, and where you're promised 10 minutes to accomplish a task but receive only 30 seconds before being verbally abused for taking too damn long, son!

In basic, success is not an option. You always fail. It's part of the game. Same goes with Coach DeSimone; you were never working hard, always slacking, always a whimp. Again, part of the game. Having survived both Coach D and boot camp, I was prepared to succeed in high pressure, time-sensitive situations. I cannot comment on combat situations, but I wonder if folks who have been in combat will tell you the same thing. I suspect they would.

Basic training is not the place to validate someone's feelings, nor is it the place to worry about someone's self-esteem. That time comes down the road, when they are entrusted with guarding a convoy, or inspecting the wing of a cargo plane for microscopic stress fractures, or generating an intelligence report that will aid those on the front lines.

It is then that the boss can wink and say, "Good job."



Comments

Thank you. You get it, you understand....though many may have felt it at the time, the military was not (though some *did* get in) looking for sadists as Company Commanders,DI's, DS's. They were looking to have motivated men and women who would unflinchingly produce Sailors, Airman, Soldiers, and Marines. Stress was supposed to be a big part of this evolution. If they legitimately can find a better way, I am all for it....but until then, why mess with success. The barbarians at the gate and elsewhere are not going to honor a "time out card", neither will their bullets avoid those who are "really stressed out at the moment". Great post!

commentPosted by: GuyS. at February 19, 2006 08:47 PM


Back Home
About Resurgemus
Full Archives
Contact


wa_finalist100.jpg





Resurgemus gets results?
Arenaria interpres
Nine point nine
Seagull Tai Chi
Sun sets on another vacation
Aramus guarauna
Catoptrophorus semipalmatus
A little schadenfreude
Alligator mississippiensis
Egretta caerulea
One, two, three, four...
Midnight Sun
Ivan
Trooper Joe's Birf-day
Frank
Bound for Del Boca Vista
I'm still sick of winter
Armstrong's Corner
How firetrucks are made
Punk


 


ruddy_turnstone_5300d_72gaso.jpg

USAFA_8264d2_crop.jpg

seagull_taichi_7193d_72gaso.jpg

pelican_sunset_4793d_72g.jpg

limpkin_7588d_72gaso.jpg

willet_7307d_72gaso.jpg

gator_vs_GBH_7704d_72gaso.jpg

gator_7598d_72gaso.jpg

little_blue_heron_7584d_72gaso.jpg


Blogworthy
Darf
Geeky stuff
Military life
Motivation
Photography
Digital Photos
Portraits Roadtrips
Sports
The Duece
Thoughts

April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005

new! - blogroll updated 1 March 2008.

Some of these weblogs may occasionally have some colorful language.

You were warned.

Daily Reading
Insta-dude
Powerline
Roger L. Simon
Winds of Change
Hot Air - new!
Blogging Heads TV - new!
Jawa Report - new!

I (club) Terrorists
Mudville Gazette
Long War Journal - new!
CT blog - new!
Austin Bay
Blackfive
Froggy Ruminations
Michael Yon

mbwb.gif
Prev | List | Random | Next Join the milblog webring Powered by RingSurf!


The Duece
Red's Trading Post - new!
PGP - new!
Books, Bikes, Broomsticks - new!
Joe Huffman's blog - new!
The Bitch Girls - new!
Les Jones - new!
Snowflakes in Hell - new!
Squeaky - new!
Alphecca
American Dinosaur
Castle Argghhh!!
Countertop Chronicles
Cowboy Blob
Geek with a .45
Hell in a Handbasket
John Lott's Website
No Looking Backwards
Mr. Completely
Of Arms and the Law
Other Side of Kim
Pass the Ammo
Paw Paw's House
Random Nuke Strikes
Say Uncle
The Smallest Minority
TFS Magnum
Trigger Finger
DIE Spammers DIE! - help fight spam email!

Humor
Scrappleface
Iowahawk
Cox & Forkum
Laurence Simon
Wizbang
IMAO

Sports Blogs
Jets Blog
NFL-Giants
Mets Geek
GeekSoapBox [mets fan]
Mets Blog
Mostly Mets
Ed Kranepool Society

Alaskan Blogs
Tim's AK Photoblog
Behind the Red
I Love Cynics
JFlame Photos
Alaska365
Northern Exposure
Frozen Images
Kodiak Konfidential
« # Alaska Blogs ? »

Photo Blogs
Snapping Photos Rick Lee
Light Infusion

Photoblogs.org
View My Profile


Other cool links
AK Volcano Observatory
Space Weather
Ted Nugent

Check these sites out
Honeydew Designs
Athanasius Kircher Soc.

Syndicate this site (XML)


Powered by
Movable Type 3.15

Designed by:

Blog Design by E.Webscapes

Technorati Profile

Blogging since
September 2005